You can download the branch yourself (git clone -b Action-Icons Redesign https://github.com/Fatih20/pencil.git) and compile it to try the new icons firsthand and provide feedbacks.

At long last, this PR is ready to be reviewed!

What are your thoughts on keeping the old icons?
For the sake of potentially being able to include the old ones again as a theme pack, the icons have been separated into theme folders:

• Legacy (old pencil)
• Classic (our current)
• Playful (the new design)

although we're currently using a combination of Legacy and Classic icons, I still thought it made sense to separate them. Should we keep or remove them?

Thanks to @Fatih20 for starting this re-design, hopefully my involvement and the changes I've made during the lifetime of this PR, hasn't made you less proud of what you started and achieved.

At long last, this PR is ready to be reviewed!

What are your thoughts on keeping the old icons? For the sake of potentially being able to include the old ones again as a theme pack, the icons have been separated into theme folders:

• Legacy (old pencil)
• Classic (our current)
• Playful (the new design)

although we're currently using a combination of Legacy and Classic icons, I still thought it made sense to separate them. Should we keep or remove them?

Thanks to @Fatih20 for starting this re-design, hopefully my involvement and the changes I've made during the lifetime of this PR, hasn't made you less proud of what you started and achieved.

Bundling or Download?

I like the idea of modular theme packs. Are we hosting them separately in the github repo tho? or are we bundling them with Pencil2D.

We could either bundle classic & "playful", leaving legacy as an optional download (Github). However I recall back then, when the original icons were changed some people did lament the icon changes. It might happen again so it could be simpler to bundle them 🤔

One minor issue

There's only one think I didn't know If I should say, but It still bothers me, and it's the hand & finger icons in the playful version. I simply never liked it from the start.

If anyone reads the conversation, I tried to nudge the OP into changing the initial version, which he agreed to, but it was never possible to come to final solution after the project was halted.

The reasons are many but mostly I want to change the shape, proportion, anatomy and visual clarity by simplifying the details both have. In that sense the Classic ones are more readable.

How to contribute to the icon packs?

Right now I don't have the time to change it, but I'll ask for reference: If I did change the SVGs, would that be easily replaced in the icon bundle via PR to contribute a potential change?

Additionally how would themes / packs work? I think with this we should consider at least some minor form of documentation so we can provide that to our users 🤔

Thank you

Other than that everything looks very vibrant and focused, so I think you did a great job taking over the overall project. Thank you 🙇‍♂️

I like the idea of modular theme packs.

Just to be clear, there are no theme packs in this PR. Oliver only organised the icons into folders within the repository so that we could potentially add theme packs in the future, but right now the icon paths used by the program are still hard-coded. Theme packs are a distinct feature which is out-of-scope for this PR.

There's only one think I didn't know If I should say, but It still bothers me, and it's the hand & finger icons in the playful version. I simply never liked it from the start.
If anyone reads the conversation, I tried to nudge the OP into changing the initial version, which he agreed to, but it was never possible to come to final solution after the project was halted.

I remember that conversation but to be fair, both the smudge and the hand icon have been redesigned several times since then though, so just to be clear, we're talking about the latest iteration, right?

In that case let's go back to the drawing board with those and improve upon them until we're satisfied.

There's only one think I didn't know If I should say, but It still bothers me, and it's the hand & finger icons in the playful version. I simply never liked it from the start.
If anyone reads the conversation, I tried to nudge the OP into changing the initial version, which he agreed to, but it was never possible to come to final solution after the project was halted.

I remember that conversation but to be fair, both the smudge and the hand icon have been redesigned several times since then though, so just to be clear, we're talking about the latest iteration, right?

In that case let's go back to the drawing board with those and improve upon them until we're satisfied.

Sorry, I forced myself to make some time to at least help. I don't want this project to be stopped bc of my comment either.

Here are some roughs for the design:
🔴 Red: Construction lines
⚫ Black: Intended outline
🔵 Blue: Optional details

Note: Please asume the construction lines to be perfectly straight lines & the circle modules are 1:1 in proportion. Finger caps are based off circles and fingers all have the same width.

I just think the base should be more modular, and then we can adapt that into the "playful" style with rounded corners. The axial guidelines for the fingers and the overlap between them in both should provide sufficient indication of perspective and the design of the "smugdes, should also be based in circular or ellipsoidal negative space (as if you cut the shapes with a boolean vector circle)

Additionally the glove details saturate the icon. If they were to e kept they could be a lighter color or we could change the pattern (horizontal instead of vertical, so it does not create a moire effect at low resolution, but ultimately if it doesn't work, I would propose to remove those lines on the back of the hands.

Thank you for taking the time to review this, and apologies I didn't mention it sooner.

Thanks for the help, I appreciate it 🙇

Meanwhile in order to not stall the PR further as you say, we'll let Jakob continue his review and merge the PR when it's done.

I'll then create a second PR later to continue the work on hand and smudge icon.

perhaps it would make sense to flip the zoom icons so the little overlay +/- is in the same corner as the layer/frame management icons

The placement was deliberate as the overlays would obscure almost the entire handle, which is imo. important to decipher the icons properly. I did end up making the overlays slightly bigger though.

What about the removal of the old icons, though? As I said before, I don’t think it’s worth keeping them around if we’re not going to use them anymore. If we do need them again, we can retrieve them from git history.

Good point. I've removed them now.

the overlays would obscure almost the entire handle

My original thought was to flip the icons… but on second thought, maybe that would be a bit unusual because it would suggest left-handed usage…

the overlays would obscure almost the entire handle

My original thought was to flip the icons… but on second thought, maybe that would be a bit unusual because it would suggest left-handed usage…

I considered it but decided against it for the reason that the majority of magnifier icons I could find were turned to the left rather than right.

With Jose being onboard with the redesigned hand and smudge icons, and Jacob having reviewed the PR, I will merge the PR 🎉